A Texas fire department took Shayn Proler off firefighting duty after complaints that he was afraid of fire. Was that discrimination? We argue the case with Julie Smith. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, and give us your verdict!

Did a silent film star kill a woman at a Hollywood party? We argue the Fatty Arbuckle case with Madison Nyikes.

Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pics and more.

Did Belgian politician Bernard Wesphael kill his wife in their seaside hotel suite? Or was her death an accident? We argue the confounding case with Jovanni Carter-Davis.

Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pictures and more. 

Leslie Mueller died in a Colorado creek while she and her husband Fred were out for a hike. Was it a freak accident or was he responsible? We argue the case with Heather Hogan.

Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pictures and more. 

Florida police caught Dalia Dippolito on tape soliciting a murder-for-hire. But she said she thought it was an audition for a reality TV show and never meant to kill anybody. Was it all a big mixup? We argue the case with Nicole Monson.

Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pics and more. 

Marissa Alexander said she fired a warning shot at her husband during an argument at their Florida home. Was it self-defense or aggravated assault? We argue the case with Emilee Leahy. 

Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram for episode pics and more. 

Did Margaret Rudin shoot her husband to death for his real estate fortune? We cover a Las Vegas whodunnit with Aimee Morris. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook.

Clemente Aguirre-Jarquin, a Honduran immigrant living in Florida, claimed he found his neighbors stabbed to death in their home and then went on trial for their murder. Was he the killer though? We argue the case with Brad Blaies. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook.

Elma Sands left a New York boarding house in December 1799 and turned up dead in the Manhattan well. Did Levi Weeks, another tenant at the boarding house, kill her? We cover a historic whodunnit with Meg Blaies. Follow @TryTrialAgain on Instagram, Twitter, and Facebook.